Myths About Real Estate Agents--What's True? What's Not?
Posted: June 15, 2018 by Taryn Celia Opie
There are so many ideas about what real estate agents do, how they do it, what they tell you and how much they make, and so many of those ideas are just plain wrong. There are lots of Internet sites that list the true and not so true about agents, so obviously there’s a bunch of curiosity and a lot of misunderstanding. Here’s my take on some of the ideas I’ve heard:
1) Real Estate Agents Make Tons of Money
We wish! Nationwide, average annual income for agents is less than $36,000 a year. In very large brokerages, about half the agents make considerably less than that. Nobody can live on that these days, and keep in mind that agent expenses that have to be paid from that income include marketing, signs, MLS fees and lockbox fees, maybe errors & omissions insurance, postage and other office supplies. And you can’t show property in our area without a vehicle, so there’s also car payments, insurance and gas… The biggest one is income taxes; brokerages hardly ever deduct income taxes, so agents have to set aside a chunk for Uncle Sam.
If you hate math, you might want to skip this paragraph. Let’s assume that a seller is willing to pay 6% of the sale price of their home. That commission is normally divided between the listing and selling brokers, and the real estate brokerage then take a “cut” of their respective commissions before writing a check to the real estate agents involved in the transaction. In addition to their company taking their “cut,” there are many expenses that real estate agents incur that most don’t realize. Items such as health insurance, fuel, car maintenance, and advertising expenses are just a handful of the expenses that real estate professionals are responsible for (see paragraph above).
2) All Real Estate Agents Are the Same
Ummm; no. Every agent has different skills, different experience levels, different personalities and different working methods. An agent who works primarily with buyers doesn’t have the same skills as one who has spent years listing and selling, for example.
3) The Less Commission You Pay, The More you Make
Really wrong. Accepting a lower commission offer from an agent (or going the For Sale by Owner route) makes you think you’ll save money. The truth is, agents who are top producers and excel in this business do not discount services. Why? Because they don't have to. It boils down to “you get what you pay for.” A 2% commission reduction doesn't amount to much when your price is discounted 10% or more because your agent couldn't afford full market exposure or the bells & whistles paid for by full-service agents, or didn’t want to spend more of a lower paycheck.
And selling “for sale by owner (FSBO)” to save lots of money? FSBO’s often end up losing money by not hiring a professional real estate agent. Why? Did the FSBO overprice the home and it didn’t sell for 6 months? Was the transaction mishandled, ending up in a buyer being declined after 3 months under contract? Did the FSBO not know how to negotiate the best price and terms for their home? Did the FSBO know where to find all the legally-required disclosure documents? And statistically, sellers who decide to do FSBO typically get offers 10% or more less than those who use agents, so where’s the savings?
4) When Selling a Home, Leave Room in the Price For Negotiating
False, false, scarily false. Correctly pricing a home is one of the top 3 important things when selling a home, and incorrect pricing can be the “kiss of death.” Pricing a home higher so that there is room for negotiations with a potential buyer can lead to frustration and even to a home that sits on the market for a long time. Today’s buyers have a different perspective; they’re savvier and better educated than ever before due to the amount of information available through the Internet and won’t waste time looking at homes overpriced by thousands of dollars.
5) Agents Must Show You Homes If You Ask
Nope. Unless you have a signed contract with an agent or that agent represents the seller, that agent you call doesn't have to show you anything. You can't call a local real estate office and demand service or demand to be shown homes, because agents don't work for free. Sellers have the right to assume that an agent’s buyer-client has been preapproved for financing, so good agents won’t show you a home unless you’ve visited with a lender. And if your call is to the listing agent, he or she can’t ethically show you a listing if you are represented by another Realtor®… without a request from that Realtor®.
6) Agents Will Say Anything to Make the Sale
Not the good ones. Although it is true that some agents will lie to you, it's unfair to paint all agents with such a broad brush. Top producing agents with a solid reputation in the community and who practice real estate honestly and truthfully, are very careful to uphold a client's trust. Making misrepresentations or a false statement is against the law. Agents who fail to disclose material facts are subject to prosecution and a loss of their license to sell real estate.
7) Agents Want You to Buy A More Expensive Home so They Make More Money
More math. Sorry. The difference between $300,000 and $310,000 is about $150 to an agent. Do you really think the agent pays any attention to the commission difference of a $10,000 spread?
8) Agents Get Kickbacks from Lenders/Title Companies/Inspectors
We can’t. Since 1974, agents have been prevented from receiving any kind of kickback or favor from real estate vendors. It's against the law. It's against RESPA: the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act. Some agents are slower than others to realize how the law affects them, but most have heard of RESPA and would not jeopardize their license, regardless of the temptation.
These are just a few of the myths surround real estate and agents, and these are also just a few of the topics we cover in regular office meetings and training sessions at our brokerage. If you have more questions, we have answers. Call us!
I found many of these suggestions for “real estate myths” on the Internet at places such as “The Lighter Side of Real Estate”, which is always good for a laugh or a good answer. Thanks for reading to the end!
-- Lee Gurr

